Hardie vs. LP SmartSide, Wood, Brick and Stucco

Vinyl isn’t the only alternative. Here’s how fiber cement stacks up against the other materials on Dallas–Fort Worth houses.

Rather talk? Call 214-349-7283

Updated November 14, 2026 · AdEx – Home Solutions, Dallas–Fort Worth

Short answer

LP SmartSide engineered wood is lighter and carries a 5/50-year warranty (5 years of full labor and materials, then prorated), while James Hardie fiber cement has a 30-year non-prorated substrate warranty and doesn’t rot. Real wood needs the most upkeep; brick, common on DFW homes, needs little but costs far more to add; stucco needs careful water management and, in Arlington, a permit.

At a glance

MaterialStrengthsWatch for
James Hardie fiber cementDoesn’t rot; non-combustible; 30-year non-prorated substrate warrantyHeavy; installation details matter; cut edges must be sealed
LP SmartSide engineered woodLighter, long boards; treated against fungal decay and termites; 5/50 warrantyProrated after year 5; keep paint and edges sealed
Real wood (cedar, pine)Natural lookRot, pests and frequent painting or staining
Brick veneerVery low maintenanceExpensive to add; mortar and weep holes need care
Stucco / EIFSSeamless lookHidden water damage if flashing fails; Arlington requires a permit

Other fiber cement brands

James Hardie is the best-known fiber cement brand, but others exist, such as Allura. Compare the warranty terms and the finish options product by product.

Common questions

Is LP SmartSide better than Hardie?

They’re different materials. LP SmartSide is engineered wood with a 5/50-year prorated warranty; Hardie is fiber cement with a 30-year non-prorated substrate warranty. Both need proper installation and sealed edges.

Does stucco need a permit?

In Arlington, yes. Check your city’s rules before starting.

This guide is general information for Texas homeowners, not legal or insurance advice. Your policy, your city and your house decide the details.